Lazarus Review

Author: Dave
Date: 03.15.14 - 6:45am

For the last month I have been exploring the Free Pascal language and Lazarus IDE.

The reason for this is because I do no want to depend on MS for the future of my applications running, and there are some capabilities I desire which VB6 does not have. (even though most of them would be not so hard to add I think):

The things that attract me to free pascal are:
  • x64 compilation
  • easy string handling
  • language is easy to transition to for VB6 users
  • unsigned and 64bit numeric types
  • rapid application development environment with all standard UI elements.
  • native compile with no external dependencies
  • same source will compile and run on Linux, Windows and many other platforms.
  • easy to integrate in with standard C modules
  • ability to create standard DLLs for use in other languages
  • capable of using pointers, inline asm, raw memory access
  • easy to use the WinApi directly if required
Overall I have been very impressed with the language. In fact the free pascal compiler and the IDE itself is all written in free pascal, and is completely open source. Dont like the way something works? change it! Once you learn the language, all the keys to this entire kingdom open before you. I LOVE that!

Lazarus IDE has been ver stable for me, I even installed it on a raspberry pi and compiled a quick program to test it.

The IDE is not as efficient to use yet as vb6. It has all of the capabilities I want, but still feels a little bit like a work in progress. Here are some wish lists:
  • debugging experience is not great, you can mouse over variables to get their values (usually) but there is no edit and continue (it may be there but you probably have to set a watch and use a separate window)
  • asm level debugger is there, but registers, memory, etc are all in scattered in separate windows
  • in general everything is in its own window, scattered all over your desktop, they save position but if you move or resize one, the others dont follow. The docking plugin didnt seem to work for me. this is fragmented and annoying.
  • There is a code navigator, again in its own window, I would love the drop downs like VB6 has to list and jump to functions. They do have a powerful code browser however which lets you search classes and methods of an entire project very efficiently. When you click an entry though it seems to only bring you to the declaration and not the implementation. Then you have to use a key sequence of CTRL-SHIFT-DOWNARROW to jump to implementation. Not bad if you know it exists I guess.
  • I would love function prototypes to display as an tooltip when you start typing in arguments. You can mouse over the function to get them, but they disappear once you type. Also you have to go into options and set the timeout to display them down low to really use them. The delay for intellisense is the same way. (update: I submitted a patch that adds this option)
  • I dont know how they survive with out an Instr like function. Luckily you can find a user created one online.
  • were back to .net levels of noise in the intellisense lists. Powerful and useful yes, but I would recommend some IDE option to hide advanced and rarely used stuff by default, and maybe reshow if a certain key sequence was hit.
  • COM integration is not great, and you have to relaunch the IDE to add new items to the toolbox. The type lib importer has some bugs. (update: I submitted a patch that adds searchable lists to select the activex control instead of having to find the file manually)
  • The LCL is the lazarus component library. Its awesome, but big. An average exe size using it is 1.2mb. A minLCL package might be cool if it could cut that down to 200-400k. Then again UPX can almost do this and is no extra labor. Not really a big deal
  • A secret little part of me wants to experiment with its language parser and switch begin/end to C style braces, and remove the := requirement or even try to make it compatible with VB6 functions and code.
All of my complaints are really just usability features, and literally things I can fix/implement on my own given that its open source. The language has all of the core attributes that I want, and is stable enough for use as is. Just want it more efficient to code and debug in.

The lure of no longer being tied to the Windows platform is also strong given their recent history of alienating developers and business users alike as they chase after tablet/mobile sales and try to turn everyone into java/html/js app developers.

There are also some language design issues I am not really keen on.

  • language is very structured, which is good and bad. you can just belt out code for small projects like you can in VB6. Every variable has to be declared, and declared at the top of a procedure in the var section. I really like declaring vars just before use
  • I used to really want the capability to define multiple classes in one file. this really makes sense for small placeholder classes that are used only for data storage. Defining multiple 30k classes in the same file however, not really on board with which this enables. Kind of a toss up as it comes to coding conventions but there is a dark side to this feature. I guess ultimately i am still on board with it. I dont like to have conventions overly defined for me.
  • The language is very tightly scoped. managing forward declarations is a little annoying. Makes you have to jump around your source file more to make a small change. Organized yes. In large projects helpful yes.
None of these things are deal breakers, but they do require more labor to implement code. I guess the bottom line is VB6 is almost perfect for what it is, and it can be stretched extremely well. Its also uber efficient and has all the right tools. Still not sure if Pascal is going to win me over for the work i do.

Comments: (3)

On 04.06.14 - 1:11pm winston potgieter wrote:
check out, it is pretty cool, coded in Lazarus, and much closer to vb6. They hope to create a vb6 project importer... I also am worried about the future of vb6, as I have 3 apps currently sold written in vb6.

On 04.06.14 - 2:31pm Dave wrote:
Cool I will check it out thanks. The first group who can pull off a seamless switch over will have an immediate following I am sure.

On 04.21.14 - 4:11am Dave wrote:
After about a month review, and submitting a couple patches to lazarus..Its a decent language, but still not as productive as VB6 to code in. (IDE, debugging, and language).

The couple added benefits such as x64 compile, 64 bit types and unsigned numbers arent a great enough draw to warrant learning all the nuances of a new language. Other barriers such as creating standard DLLs, or linking in C Obj files into VB6 executables, I was able to remove. I also dont care for the executable sizes. 68k vb6 dll vrs a 1mb pascal dll.

The one real remaining consideration left for me is the Linux support which is really cool, but I still dont use linux on a regular basis so moot.

VB6 + C where needed is still the winning combination for me. Being able to compile the C Obj files directly into VB is also a killer capability too.

Leave Comment:
Email: (not shown)
Message: (Required)
Math Question: 85 + 9 = ? followed by the letter: S 

About Me
More Blogs
Main Site
Posts: (year)
2024 (2)
     ffmpeg voodoo
     RegJump Vb
2023 (9)
     VB6 Virtual Files
     File handles across dlls
     python abort / script timeout
     VB6 Python embed w/debugger
     python embedding
     VB6 IDE Enhancements
     No Sleep
     A2W no ATL
2022 (4)
     More VB6 - C data passing
     Vb6 Asm listing
     Byte Array C to VB6
     Planet Source Code DVDs
2021 (2)
     Obscure VB
     VB6 IDE SP6
2020 (4)
     BSTR from C Dll to VB
     Cpp Memory Manipulation
     ActiveX Binary Compatability
2019 (5)
     Console tricks
     FireFox temp dir
     OCX License
     Extract substring
     VB6 Console Apps
2018 (6)
     VB6 UDTs
     VB6 Debugger View As Hex tooltips
     VB6 - C Share registry data
     VB6 Addin Missing Menus
     VB6 Class Init Params
     VB6 isIn function
2017 (6)
     Python and VB6
     Python pros and cons
     download web Dir
     vc rand in python
     VB6 Language Enhancement
     Register .NET as COM
2016 (22)
     VB6 CDECL
     UDT Tricks pt2
     Remote Data Extraction
     Collection Extender
     VB6 FindResource
     DirList Single Click
     Reset CheckPoint VPN Policy
     VB6 BSTR Oddities Explained
     SafeArrays in C
     BSTR and Variant in C++
     Property let optional args
     Misc Libs
     Enum Named Pipes
     Vb6 Collection in C++
     VB6 Overloaded Methods
     VB6 Syncronous Socket
     Simple IPC
     VB6 Auto Resize Form Elements
     Mach3 Automation
     Exit For in While
2015 (15)
     C# self register ocx
     VB6 Class Method Pointers
     Duktape Debug Protocol
     QtScript 4 VB
     Vb6 Named Args
     vb6 Addin Part 2
     VB6 Addin vrs Toolbars
     OpenFile Dialog MultiSelect
     Duktape Example
     DukTape JS
     VB6 Unsigned
     .Net version
     TitleBar Height
     .NET again
     VB6 Self Register OCXs
2014 (25)
     Query Last 12 Mos
     Progid from Interface ID
     VB6 to C Array Examples
     Human Readable Variant Type
     ScriptBasic COM Integration
     CodeView Addin
     ScriptBasic - Part 2
     Script Env
     MSCOMCTL Win7 Error
     printf override
     History Combo
     Disable IE
     API Hooking in VB6
     Addin Hook Events
     FastBuild Addin
     VB6 MemoryWindow
     Link C Obj Files into VB6
     Vb6 Standard Dlls
     CStr for Pascal
     Lazarus Review
     asprintf for VS
     VB6 GlobalMultiUse
     Scintilla in VB6
     Dynamic Highlight
     WinVerifyTrust, CryptMsgGetParam VB6
2013 (4)
     MS GLEE Graphing
     printf for VB6
     C# App Config
     Tero DES C# Test
2012 (10)
     VC 2008 Bit Fields
     Speed trap
     C# Db Class Generator
     VB6 vrs .NET (again)
     FireFox Whois Extension
     git and vb6
     Code Additions
     Compiled date to string
     C# ListView Sorter
     VB6 Wish List
2011 (7)
     C# Process Injection
     CAPTCHA Bots
     C# PE Offset Calculator
     VB6 Async Download
     Show Desktop
     coding philosophy
     Code release
2010 (11)
     Dll Not Found in IDE
     Advanced MSScript Control
     random tip
     Clipart / Vector Art
     VB6 Callback from C#
     Binary data from VB6 to C#
     CSharp and MsScriptControl
     HexDumper functions
     Js Beautify From VB6 or C#
     vb6 FormPos
     Inline Asm w VB6
2009 (3)
     The .NET Fiasco
     One rub on computers
     Universal extractor