ActiveX Binary Compatability


Author: Dave
Date: 03.01.20 - 8:35am



Apparently there are some unspoken truths about the finer points of COM binary compatibility that I never realized even after 20 years of extensive use!

This all started the other day when I added a new enum value to a project and didnt realize I had binary compatibility already set. The project compiled fine. When it dawned on me what had just happened, it made me realize the rules to binary compatibility may not be as strict as I had assumed been told.

Early on in my career it was an annoyance not being able to update prototypes and I learned just to not transition to ActiveX to early. Whenever I really wanted a new interface into a library, I would create a whole new MyClass2 and retool it as needed. Occasionally I would just simply break compatibility and recompile/redistribute everything that used that lib if it was still early enough along but that kinda sucks.

What I had always been told about binary compatibility was that once you created a public interface in an ActiveX dll, it was a binary contract and could not be changed no matter what.

This is true, but apparently it is not the whole story. While you cant change what has already been published, you CAN add new stuff to the interface. Below are some tests to explore the limits:

Fails:
  • changing arg of existing function to byval
  • adding optional args to existing function
  • change existing arg to optional
  • change prototype of a function for implemented class
  • change a prototype in a not creatable implemented class
Ok additions:
  • adding new enum values
  • adding a new function at end of class
  • adding a new function at start of class
  • add implements to existing class (not creatable)
  • return private class from public class as object
  • change any prototype in this private class
One thing i had been thinking of for a while was to always include a generic prototype into my binary compatibly classes like:
 function futureProof(operation as long, arg1, arg2, arg3)
but this is no longer necessary with the ability to freely add new functions to published classes.

I have been using vb6 for 20 years and ActiveX dlls extensively for this entire time and never realized this finer point.

Another idea I had, in terms of being able to return a private class with no limitations, how do you self document that classes prototypes since VB does not support reflection? Simple answer..vb can support reflection...if we do it ourselves.

We could easily have a self.describe() method that returns a collection of all of the prototypes of the public members in the class along with their help string. It would be a simple task to write a tool or addin which extracts prototypes and auto generates the describe method. The classView addin already has the logic for this. It could even be done automatically on compilation.

With a unified format for this, you could easily integrate it into code completion tools for scripts or build out a .Call() function to then execute the functions "through reflection" from other vb6 code. Its not a common need, but its not beyond our capability to add to the language with CallByName and variants. As a bonus, we get to choose who can reach into our classes rather than having all of our metadata automatically published by a shitty bloated power grabbing framework language like Java or .NET...but i digress...






Comments: (0)

 
Leave Comment:
Name:
Email: (not shown)
Message: (Required)
Math Question: 8 + 57 = ? followed by the letter: U 



About Me
More Blogs
Main Site
Posts: (year)
2024 (3)
     VB6 JSON
     ffmpeg voodoo
     RegJump Vb
2023 (9)
     VB6 Virtual Files
     File handles across dlls
     python abort / script timeout
     py4vb
     VB6 Python embed w/debugger
     python embedding
     VB6 IDE Enhancements
     No Sleep
     A2W no ATL
2022 (4)
     More VB6 - C data passing
     Vb6 Asm listing
     Byte Array C to VB6
     Planet Source Code DVDs
2021 (2)
     Obscure VB
     VB6 IDE SP6
2020 (4)
     NTFileSize
     BSTR from C Dll to VB
     Cpp Memory Manipulation
     ActiveX Binary Compatability
2019 (5)
     Console tricks
     FireFox temp dir
     OCX License
     Extract substring
     VB6 Console Apps
2018 (6)
     VB6 UDTs
     VB6 Debugger View As Hex tooltips
     VB6 - C Share registry data
     VB6 Addin Missing Menus
     VB6 Class Init Params
     VB6 isIn function
2017 (6)
     Python and VB6
     Python pros and cons
     download web Dir
     vc rand in python
     VB6 Language Enhancement
     Register .NET as COM
2016 (22)
     VB6 CDECL
     UDT Tricks pt2
     Remote Data Extraction
     Collection Extender
     VB6 FindResource
     CDO.Message
     DirList Single Click
     Reset CheckPoint VPN Policy
     VB6 BSTR Oddities Explained
     SafeArrays in C
     BSTR and Variant in C++
     Property let optional args
     Misc Libs
     Enum Named Pipes
     Vb6 Collection in C++
     VB6 Overloaded Methods
     EXPORT FUNCDNAME Warning
     VB6 Syncronous Socket
     Simple IPC
     VB6 Auto Resize Form Elements
     Mach3 Automation
     Exit For in While
2015 (15)
     C# self register ocx
     VB6 Class Method Pointers
     Duktape Debug Protocol
     QtScript 4 VB
     Vb6 Named Args
     vb6 Addin Part 2
     VB6 Addin vrs Toolbars
     OpenFile Dialog MultiSelect
     Duktape Example
     DukTape JS
     VB6 Unsigned
     .Net version
     TitleBar Height
     .NET again
     VB6 Self Register OCXs
2014 (25)
     Query Last 12 Mos
     Progid from Interface ID
     VB6 to C Array Examples
     Human Readable Variant Type
     ScriptBasic COM Integration
     CodeView Addin
     ScriptBasic - Part 2
     Script Env
     MSCOMCTL Win7 Error
     printf override
     History Combo
     Disable IE
     API Hooking in VB6
     Addin Hook Events
     FastBuild Addin
     VB6 MemoryWindow
     Link C Obj Files into VB6
     Vb6 Standard Dlls
     CStr for Pascal
     Lazarus Review
     asprintf for VS
     VB6 GlobalMultiUse
     Scintilla in VB6
     Dynamic Highlight
     WinVerifyTrust, CryptMsgGetParam VB6
2013 (4)
     MS GLEE Graphing
     printf for VB6
     C# App Config
     Tero DES C# Test
2012 (10)
     VC 2008 Bit Fields
     Speed trap
     C# Db Class Generator
     VB6 vrs .NET (again)
     FireFox Whois Extension
     git and vb6
     Code Additions
     Compiled date to string
     C# ListView Sorter
     VB6 Wish List
2011 (7)
     C# Process Injection
     CAPTCHA Bots
     C# PE Offset Calculator
     VB6 Async Download
     Show Desktop
     coding philosophy
     Code release
2010 (11)
     Dll Not Found in IDE
     Advanced MSScript Control
     random tip
     Clipart / Vector Art
     VB6 Callback from C#
     Binary data from VB6 to C#
     CSharp and MsScriptControl
     HexDumper functions
     Js Beautify From VB6 or C#
     vb6 FormPos
     Inline Asm w VB6
2009 (3)
     The .NET Fiasco
     One rub on computers
     Universal extractor